Oblate Safeguarding Commission

Oblates of Mary Immaculate Receive Report on the Oblate Safeguarding Commission

TÉLÉCHARGEZ VERSION FRANÇAISE

Report of the Oblate Safeguarding Commission: ENGLISH – FRANÇAIS – INUKTITUT

Following a commitment to independently review the congregation’s response to historical allegations of sexual abuse against Joannès Rivoire in present-day Nunavut, including the circumstances under which he left Canada, OMI Lacombe Canada and the Oblates of the Province of France (the “Oblates”) appointed Justice André Denis to lead the Oblate Safeguarding Commission.

The commission aimed to better understand how these allegations were addressed by Oblates, listen to victims and their families, and identify any improvements to Oblate governance, policies and processes that can safeguard children and ensure a high level of accountability. On March 15, 2024, the Oblate Safeguarding Commission issued its final report.

The report found that the allegations made against Joannès Rivoire were well-founded.

“I wish to thank Justice Denis for his thorough, independent report and to apologize to anyone who was harmed by an Oblate,” said Fr. Ken Thorson, Provincial for OMI Lacombe Canada. “Further, I wish to apologize that we did not move quicker in reviewing this history. Our first responsibility is to safeguard minors who put their trust in us, and we were part of a systemic failure to do this. This is something that I carry.”

“I wish to sincerely thank those who had the courage to come forward, the Inuit community for their guidance, and all who have participated in this process,” he continued. “Their strength and wisdom light the path we will follow in pursuit of justice, healing, and reconciliation. Moving forward, we will continue to cooperate fully with legal authorities and the community and are determined to ensure our governance and policies reflect the highest standards of safeguarding and ethical accountability.”

Additional findings from the report state that:

• The Oblates in Canada and the ecclesiastical authorities in Nunavut neither concealed nor organized Joannès Rivoire’s flight from Canada to France in 1993;
• The Oblates were unaware that he was wanted by the Canadian justice system when he arrived in France on sabbatical in 1993;
• As soon as they learned of the Canadian proceedings, Oblate authorities removed Joannès Rivoire from any ecclesiastical mission and from any function in the Oblate community and;
• The Oblates did “everything in their power to ensure that he returned to Canada to stand trial or be extradited.”

OMI Lacombe Canada has taken significant steps to develop and continually enhance our policy, “Exercising Responsibility in Our Ministry: Safeguarding Minors & Vulnerable Persons,” that sets processes and best practices to preserve the safety of minors and vulnerable persons.

While nothing can reverse the harm and tragic legacy of clerical abuse, it is our hope this report provides some validation for those who were silenced and ignored countless times by numerous institutions and authority figures across this country.

For further information:

Report of the Oblate Safeguarding Commission: ENGLISH – FRANÇAIS – INUKTITUT

Statement of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate – OMI Lacombe Canada and the Oblates of the Province of France: ENGLISH – FRANÇAIS

Bio – Justice André Denis – DOWNLOAD PDF: ENGLISH / FRANÇAIS

Justice André Denis is a retired judge of the Superior Court of Quebec, where he had a distinguished career from 1991 to 2015. During this period and for a period of two years, he also served as an ad hoc judge at the Quebec Court of Appeal.

As a Superior Court Justice, he presided over Canada’s first trial involving the Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act, which resulted in the conviction of Désiré Munyaneza for seven counts of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes committed in and around Butare, Rwanda, where his family was based.

In December 2020, Justice Denis was hired by the Archdiocese of Montreal to work on two mandates regarding allegations of sexual abuse of minors and vulnerable people.

• Under the first mandate, André Denis reviewed all relevant diocesan files to identify any indication of unacceptable abuse perpetrated against minors from those who were presently serving the diocese.
• Under the second mandate, André Denis conducted a statistical audit to identify the confirmed or well-founded instances of sexual abuse attributed to bishops, priests, permanent deacons, pastoral personnel, and staff working in parochial-related ministries. After reviewing the archived files of 6,809 people employed between 1940 and 2021, he confirmed 87 employees who were subjects of confirmed or well-founded allegations.

His work provided the Archdiocese of Montreal with information that helped it understand the scope of the problem before taking concrete steps in pursuit of truth, transparency, and transformation.

FAQ – DOWNLOAD PDF: ENGLISH / FRANÇAIS

What is the Safeguarding Commission?

The Oblate Safeguarding Commission is an independent review of historical allegations of sexual abuse relating to Joannès Rivoire in present-day Nunavut, including the circumstances under which he left Canada. It aimed to better understand how past allegations of abuse were addressed within our congregation and identify any improvements to Oblate policies and governance in order to better safeguard minors and ensure a high-level of accountability.

The commission was led by the Honourable André Denis who issued a final written report in English, French and Inuktitut on March 15, 2024.

Who is Justice Denis?

Justice Denis is a retired judge of the Superior Court of Quebec who has had a distinguished career in the judiciary, including as the first judge in Canada to preside over a trial involving the Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act. In December 2020, he was hired by the Archdiocese of Montreal to work on two mandates regarding allegations of sexual abuse of minors and vulnerable people.

Denis reviewed almost 10,000 files dating from 1940 to 2021 and compiled a report covering the nine dioceses of the Ecclesiastical Province of Montreal and the Ecclesiastical Province of Gatineau. The report that he oversaw uncovered 87 employees who were the subjects of confirmed or well-founded sex abuse allegations involving minors or vulnerable adults, providing the Archdiocese with information that helped it understand the scope of the problem before taking concrete steps in pursuit of truth, transparency, and transformation.

How have the Oblates responded to the allegations against Joannès Rivoire?

Joannès Rivoire has been accused, and formally charged, for sexually abusing Inuit children in the 1960s and 1970s while working in Nunavut, Canada. These long-standing allegations have caused great suffering, anger and intergenerational wounds in the people the Oblates have served for 150 years.

As Oblates, we are fully committed to contributing to healing these wounds, and to the larger journey of healing and reconciliation with Canada’s Indigenous Peoples. The Oblates of Mary Immaculate in Canada have urged Rivoire to make himself available to the justice system, and to engage in this process for truth, transparency, and eventual reconciliation. We have also proactively supported Canada’s extradition request and proactively reached out to the Ministry of Justice, offering to cooperate with any investigation.

The Oblates have been working directly with survivors to provide support to the Inuit community. This commission followed a commitment to independently review the congregation’s response to sexual abuse allegations against Joannès Rivoire, including the circumstances under which he left Canada.

What did the Commission’s work entail?

Justice Denis was mandated to hear from victims and their families and identify any improvements to Oblate policies and processes that can better safeguard children and ensure a high-level of accountability.

We recognize that this subject matter is inherently difficult for many survivors or intergenerational survivors to engage in. Justice Denis was expected to take reasonable steps to accommodate them at times and formats that meet their respective needs.

All relevant personnel records and other archival material from the Oblate provinces of Lacombe and France were made available to Justice Denis, and a final written report was issued on March 15, 2024.

What did the Commission find?

The report found that the allegations made against Joannès Rivoire were well founded. It also stated that the Oblates in Canada and the ecclesiastical authorities in Nunavut neither concealed nor organized Joannès Rivoire’s flight from Canada to France in 1993 and that the Oblates did “everything in their power to ensure that he returned to Canada to stand trial or be extradited.”

Justice Denis referred to our policy “Exercising Responsibility in Our Ministry: Safeguarding Minors & Vulnerable Persons,” that sets processes and best practices to preserve the safety of minors and vulnerable persons, as comprehensive, covering everything from prevention to denunciation to intervention by authorities.

We accept the report’s conclusions with a heavy heart. We wish to apologize unequivocally to anyone who was harmed by an Oblate priest and to continue taking concrete steps towards transparency and transformation, informed by guidance from victims, survivors and Inuit representatives.

What do the Oblates intend to do with the Commission’s findings?

The Oblates hope this commission contributes to the process of healing for the survivors and intergenerational survivors of clergy abuse. We sincerely thank those who had the courage to come forward, the Inuit community for their guidance, and all who have participated in this process.

Moving forward, we will continue to cooperate fully with legal authorities and the community and are determined to ensure our governance and policies reflect the highest standards of safeguarding and ethical accountability.

Why was the Commission focused on allegations against Joannès Rivoire?

This commission met a previous commitment to independently review the congregation’s response to sexual abuse allegations against Joannès Rivoire, including the circumstances under which he left Canada. The Oblates recognize the tragic legacy of clergy abuse and are sincerely committed to support the Inuit Peoples who advocate for truth, justice, healing, and reconciliation.

Oblates of Mary Immaculate Appoint the Honourable André Denis to Lead Safeguarding Commission

DOWNLOAD PDF: ENGLISH / FRANÇAIS

The Oblates of Mary Immaculate, OMI Lacombe Canada and the Oblates of the Province of France (the “Oblates”) have appointed Justice André Denis to lead the Oblate Safeguarding Commission, an independent review of historical allegations of sexual abuse against Johannes Rivoire in present-day Nunavut.

This commission meets a previous commitment to independently review the congregation’s response to these allegations, including the circumstances under which he left Canada. It aims to better understand how past allegations of abuse were addressed within the congregation and identify any improvements to Oblate policies and governance in order to better safeguard minors and ensure a high level of accountability.

“The Oblates recognize the tragic legacy of clergy abuse and are sincerely committed to support the Inuit Peoples who advocate for truth, justice, healing, and reconciliation,” said Fr. Ken Thorson, Provincial for OMI Lacombe Canada. “It is my hope that Justice André Denis’ work will contribute to the process of healing for the survivors and intergenerational survivors of clergy abuse.”

“I appreciate the opportunity to lead this commission and expect that my findings will contribute to greater understanding of this history, while positioning the Oblates to set a higher standard of accountability and safety,” said Justice André Denis. “I believe that my experience on the Quebec Superior Court and completing two public review processes for the Archdiocese of Montreal positions me well to take on this important project.”

All relevant personnel records and other archival material from the Oblate provinces of OMI Lacombe Canada and France will be made available to Justice André Denis, and a final written report will be made public in English, French and Inuktitut no later than April 1, 2024.

About the Honourable André Denis

Justice André Denis is a retired judge of the Superior Court of Quebec who has had a distinguished career in the judiciary, including as the first judge in Canada to preside over a trial involving the Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act. In December 2020, he was hired by the Archdiocese of Montreal to work on two mandates regarding allegations of sexual abuse of minors and vulnerable people.

Denis reviewed almost 10,000 files dating from 1940 to 2021 and compiled a report covering the nine dioceses of the Ecclesiastical Province of Montreal and the Ecclesiastical Province of Gatineau. The report that he oversaw uncovered 87 employees who were the subjects of confirmed or well-founded sex abuse allegations involving minors or vulnerable adults, providing the Archdiocese with information that helped it understand the scope of the problem before taking concrete steps in pursuit of truth, transparency, and transformation.

For further information: OMI Lacombe Canada – Oblate Safeguarding Commission

To contribute to the Oblate Safeguarding Commission and to contact Justice André Denis: j.andredenis@icloud.com.

Bio – Justice André Denis

DOWNLOAD PDF: ENGLISH / FRANÇAIS

Justice André Denis is a retired judge of the Superior Court of Quebec, where he had a distinguished career from 1991 to 2015. During this period and for a period of two years, he also served as an ad hoc judge at the Quebec Court of Appeal.

As a Superior Court Justice, he presided over Canada’s first trial involving the Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act, which resulted in the conviction of Désiré Munyaneza for seven counts of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes committed in and around Butare, Rwanda, where his family was based.

In December 2020, Justice Denis was hired by the Archdiocese of Montreal to work on two mandates regarding allegations of sexual abuse of minors and vulnerable people.

• Under the first mandate, André Denis reviewed all relevant diocesan files to identify any indication of unacceptable abuse perpetrated against minors from those who were presently serving the diocese.
• Under the second mandate, André Denis conducted a statistical audit to identify the confirmed or well-founded instances of sexual abuse attributed to bishops, priests, permanent deacons, pastoral personnel, and staff working in parochial-related ministries. After reviewing the archived files of 6,809 people employed between 1940 and 2021, he confirmed 87 employees who were subjects of confirmed or well-founded allegations.

His work provided the Archdiocese of Montreal with information that helped it understand the scope of the problem before taking concrete steps in pursuit of truth, transparency, and transformation.

FAQ

DOWNLOAD PDF: ENGLISH / FRANÇAIS

What is the Safeguarding Commission?
The Oblate Safeguarding Commission is an independent review of historical allegations of sexual abuse relating to Johannes Rivoire in present-day Nunavut, including the circumstances under which he left Canada. It aims to better understand how past allegations of abuse were addressed within our congregation and identify any improvements to Oblate policies and governance in order to better safeguard minors and ensure a high-level of accountability.

The commission is led by the Honourable André Denis who will issue a final written report in English, French and Inuktitut no later than April 1, 2024. The report will outline findings and provide recommendations on policy and governance improvements for addressing any future complaints.

Who is Justice Denis?
Justice Denis is a retired judge of the Superior Court of Quebec who has had a distinguished career in the judiciary, including as the first judge in Canada to preside over a trial involving the Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act. In December 2020, he was hired by the Archdiocese of Montreal to work on two mandates regarding allegations of sexual abuse of minors and vulnerable people.

Denis reviewed almost 10,000 files dating from 1940 to 2021 and compiled a report covering the nine dioceses of the Ecclesiastical Province of Montreal and the Ecclesiastical Province of Gatineau. The report that he oversaw uncovered 87 employees who were the subjects of confirmed or well-founded sex abuse allegations involving minors or vulnerable adults, providing the Archdiocese with information that helped it understand the scope of the problem before taking concrete steps in pursuit of truth, transparency, and transformation.

How have the Oblates responded to the allegations against Johannes Rivoire?
Johannes Rivoire has been accused, and formally charged, for sexually abusing Inuit children in the 1960s and 1970s while working in Nunavut, Canada. These long-standing allegations have caused great suffering, anger and intergenerational wounds in the people the Oblates have served for 150 years.

As Oblates, we are fully committed to contributing to healing these wounds, and to the larger journey of healing and reconciliation with Canada’s Indigenous Peoples. The Oblates of Mary Immaculate in Canada have urged Rivoire to make himself available to the justice system, and to engage in this process for truth, transparency, and eventual reconciliation. We have also proactively supported Canada’s extradition request and proactively reached out to the Ministry of Justice, offering to cooperate with any investigation.
The Oblates have been working directly with survivors to provide support to the Inuit community. This commission follows a commitment to independently review the congregation’s response to sexual abuse allegations against Johannes Rivoire, including the circumstances under which he left Canada.

What will the Commission’s work entail?
Justice Denis will hear from victims and their families and identify any improvements to Oblate policies and processes that can better safeguard children and ensure a high-level of accountability.

We recognize that this subject matter is inherently difficult for many survivors or intergenerational survivors to engage in and expect Justice Denis to take reasonable steps to accommodate them at times and formats that meet their respective needs.

All relevant personnel records and other archival material from the Oblate provinces of Lacombe and France will be made available to Justice Denis, and we expect to receive a final written report no later than April 1, 2024.

What do the Oblates intend to do with the Commission’s findings?
The goal of the commission is to better understand how past allegations of abuse were addressed by our congregation, with emphasis on claims made against Johannes Rivoire and other complaints in Nunavut, and to identify any improvements to Oblate policies and processes that can better safeguard children and ensure a high-level of accountability.

The Oblates hope this commission contributes to the process of healing for the survivors and intergenerational survivors of clergy abuse. The congregation recognizes their immense courage as we seek to learn from historical wrongdoings and move forward with meaningful improvements.

Why is the Commission focused on allegations against Johannes Rivoire?
This commission meets a previous commitment to independently review the congregation’s response to sexual abuse allegations against Johannes Rivoire, including the circumstances under which he left Canada. The Oblates recognize the tragic legacy of clergy abuse and are sincerely committed to support the Inuit Peoples who advocate for truth, justice, healing, and reconciliation.

How can I participate?
To contribute to the Oblate Safeguarding Commission and contact Justice André Denis: j.andredenis@icloud.com